Showing posts with label #CoopExt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label #CoopExt. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Assigning moderators for concurrent sessions

One of the parts I enjoyed most in serving as Education Program Committee Chair was in working with the oral session moderators. This is an area in which the committee became actively involved. In addition, this provided opportunity for interaction and networking in preparation for the conference.

As people submitted proposals to the conference system they were asked if they were willing to moderate a session. Some people had no recollection of this step in the process and were surprised when I contacted them to see if they were still willing to serve as moderators. But many were willing and excited to serve in this role. I think this volunteer process was good, but unfortunately missed those who did not indicate interest in giving a presentation and who may have benefitted by playing this role. In making assignments, I primarily looked at association membership since, as you recall, oral assignments were made by association. Because people had submitted presentations I also had a sense of what their interests were and tried to use these in making assignments as well.

When I met with the committee prior to completion of the assignments we agreed that it might be beneficial to provide a moderators guide to all moderators. This was intended to increase confidence of those who may have been playing this role for the first time and to provide consistency since each of the participating associations has their own culture around presentations. One of the committee members took responsibility for developing the guide. The committee reviewed and approved it for use.

The initial communication with the moderator was simply a reminder of their previous indication of interest in serving in the role and to check their availability for a particular session. If they agreed to serve, they were sent the session time, topics and abstracts and a copy of the moderators guide. The presenters were copied on this so they were aware of the expectations, and many moderators and presenters began communication by email immediately, introducing themselves and preparing for the session. Closer to the time of the conference, the biographical information provided by the presenters in the submission system, was sent to the moderators, again with a copy to the presenters. In the email, the source of the information was provided and presenters were encouraged to share additional information that they thought would be of interest to the audience. At this time presenters and moderators were also aware of time constraints so they were also able to prioritize information to provide maximum presentation time.

These communications were very well received by both presenters and moderators. Many individuals expressed appreciation for this information once we arrived at the conference. There also seemed to be more of a sense of community and collaboration – people were aware of the roles and the importance of those roles. They also knew each other, at least virtually, so looked forward to seeing each other in person. This created a very positive atmosphere for the educational programs. In addition, it gave moderators and presenters ownership in this aspect of the conference. There are always going to be a few things that don’t go quite as planned, but these individuals were empowered with the committee members to do what needed to be done to make the program run as smoothly as possible.

Final communication with moderators followed the conference. The message included a thank you, but also asked for participant numbers, observed movement between sessions and asked for their recommendations regarding number of presenters or other concerns that might be addressed in the final document. Nearly 50% responded. Many seemed extremely pleased to have been asked and this provided a nice closure to their activity. It may have increased responses to some extent to have let them know this email would be coming.

Recommendations for the future:

  1. I liked the way moderators were assigned. If the conference moved toward topical tracks, moderators might be assigned by the committees that make the selections and could moderate multiple sessions.
  2. Communication with moderators and presenters is important and worth the time it takes. Make it happen!

If you have questions or would like further information about this process or the final report, please contact me at kvines@psu.edu.

Monday, January 7, 2013

Extension Calendar Observations for 2012

Many of you know that in the past year I’ve been spending a lot of time thinking about how we market extension programs.   Although my primary emphasis has been on the use of Cvent, I also have been considering how we use the Extension Calendar to market our programs and events.  As the year comes to a close, here are some of my observations that you might consider as you add programs for the coming year as well as some interesting facts and figures.
These recommendations are based on an average of 98 calendar entries reviewed each month between June and December. [1]  In general, I found an average of 140 potential issues each month, but am pleased to report this has declined from a little over 2 issues per entry in June to 1.58 issues per entry in December. 
What are the issues?  Here are the top three I’ve seen along with an explanation of how they might be avoided.
#1 – Using PDFs for registration or to provide additional information.  PDFs are often slow to download from computers and are useless with mobile devices.  Instead of a PDF, enter the information about the event into the calendar entry page.  This will make it easier for your potential audience to see the information.
#2 – Issues related to content.  There are several ways the content of your entry can impact the likelihood of attendance by your potential audience.  What you present and how you present it is important.
First, answer the basic questions:  
·         Who is the intended audience?
·         Why should they attend?  What should they learn or be able to do after attending?
·         What do people need to do to attend?  This includes advance registration.  Be sure to indicate how people should register and indicate if there is a registration date.   Any registration cost should be stated.  Also, let people know if the event is free.
·         Where is the event being held?  Most of the time this is covered in the address section.  However many of our events are online these days.  Be sure to tell the attendee what to expect when they go to a link.  For example:  “You will want to log-in to http://meeting.psu.edu/xxxx  to participate in the webinar.   This meeting room will be monitored beginning 10 minutes prior to the program.”  Also, with webinars, it might be useful on the meeting screen, if you leave the meeting room open, to post a message indicating the topic, date and time of the next session so that if someone goes there to test the link, they will know they are in the right place.  In the college calendar system, you can also select webinar in order to have the event appear on the Extension webinar calendar.
·         Who do I contact if I have questions or a problem?  It is also good practice to include a name and contact phone number in case participants have difficulty accessing the program.
Finally, don’t provide extraneous information.  Just provide the information that is relevant to that particular calendar entry.  If you are working with an event that has multiple meetings/locations across the state (i.e. ServSafe, Better Kid Care), you may refer to a calendar landing page for other events, but don’t try to list these on this particular entry.   If you don’t have a calendar landing page and need one, discuss it with your program team and EPL.
#3 – List a contact person.  We are a people organization, so include a contact person, email address and phone number so potential participants know who to call if they have questions.  Some offices are having email go to an office email account.  This is fine as well, but be sure the link that is used is descriptive.  For instance, if the contact for the event is the Beaver County Extension Office, use Penn State Extension – Beaver County Office rather than just Penn State Extension.  Along these lines, if you are working with another organization, it is okay to indicate that in the content of the calendar entry.  However, the contact person for our Extension calendar should be someone affiliated with Penn State Extension.
Finally – for some stats from the entries I viewed – only 43 counties and 22 programs posted entries on the Extension Calendar during this timeframe.  The Private Forests program and Lebanon County team take the prize for posting, having at least one entry every month between June and December.  Missing only one month during this time frame were Adams County, Equine Programs and the Start Farming Program. 



[1] For other recommendations, consult “Events” on the Communications and Marketing Website (http://agsci.psu.edu/communications/web/best-practices/events). 

Friday, August 31, 2012

Social Media for Cooperative Extension

One of my areas of thought and inquiry lately has been around the role of social media in developing and reaching extension audiences.  Extension has long prided itself on the relationships formed between the clientele and extension professional in the field.  Most of these relationships were face-to-face and I know I've talked about this in previous posts.  In "face-to-face" we have best opportunity for building those high quality relationships that build on the regular interaction, ability to "really see" what someone is talking about and ability to read body language and facial expressions that clue us into the importance of what is being discussed.  As extension professionals we have access to a wealth of valuable, research-based information that can be interpreted and implemented for local situations.  How do we do that from a distance now that we have to cover larger geographical areas to reach the same number of clients?  And better yet, how do we measure success?

The July 28 issue of Inside Higher Ed featured a story, Tweeting by Faith that reports that universities as a whole believe social media is a valuable tool but are ineffective in measuring what the tool is contributing to the organization.  They remain caught up in measuring number of friends, likes, followers, etc. which indicate people are available to hear and possibly listening, but don't really indicate that our message is getting across and used.

I previously reviewed a slide presentation from "Information Management" on the 9 Challenges with Social Media Metrics and share with you now what they identified as challenges and some of my thoughts on how they relate to Extension. 
  1.  Response Tracking - This goes back to what we are measuring.  And to go beyond likes, retweets and shares we have to know who is using the content so we can later identify what change the information inspired.  This would require some type of "registration" which is a turn-off to many people when they are surfing.  Personally, if I see it and its not a site I already value, I'm not likely to register.  Someone could go in and make lists of those initial respondents perhaps and message them later to get follow-up information realted to how they used the information.
  2. Audience - Are we successful in reaching the desired audience?  Of course this also assumes we sat down initially in planning our campaign and identified our audience.  In this we also need to know whether our message is going out at the proper level for the intended audience.  The message will be different for a beginning versus an advanced client.
  3. Monitoring - Are we using social media to listen to how well we are performing.  What are our clients saying about us when we aren't directing the conversation.  This week there has been a great outpouring of support for Cooperative Extension related to our horticulture resources on the #CoopExt tag.  It's refreshing to see that, but who is watching.  And we can sit back and smile now, but if the message were negative would we be prepared to respond effectively and quickly?
  4. Content analysis - We need to be sure that what we are producing is of the highest quality and usefulness to the intended audience.  Also, when we retweet or share other's messages we need to be sure it meets our quality requirements.
  5. Connections - The article recommends some software that can be used to measure the strength of the connections that are being made on behalf of your social media presence.
  6. Traffic analysis - What kind of interactions are taking place as a result of those connections?  Are they improving our reputation and reliability and helping to spread the intended message?
  7. Influence - Klout has made us all aware that different people are on different levels of the influence chart.  We need to know how many people/companies of influence are supporting our programs through connections, messages sent, retransmission, links and comments.  I've always felt our messages were much stronger when someone else from the outside shared them as our message.  (Which emphasizes need for our clarity in delivering the intended message to the intended audience.)
  8. Case Management - Do we follow-up with issues and challenges that are identified in a timely manner?
  9. Cross-platform identities - How do we manage our identities for different forms of media to best utilize the attributes of that media?  Audiences often differ by media as do limitations and types of information that are appropriate to be shared.
How is your cooperative extension program measuring impact through social media?  Do you include it in your regular reports?  Does today's evaluation influence planning for future educational efforts?  And finally, how are you monitoring your message?  I look forward to hearing from you.

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Extension Excellence

I learned this morning about the Extension Excellence program and website (http://excellence.tamu.edu/) which apparently has been in existence from planning to implementation for the past 7 years now.  "About Excellence" indicates the program began through the formation of a task force by ECOP to find ways to measure excellence in Extension.  The team includes a director and evaluator for each region of the US with representatives for the 1890 schools as well.

There are seven criteria with appropriate measures identified for program evaluation.  The criteria, as listed on the website, are as follows:
1. The university recognizes Cooperative Extension as a major component of outreach/engagement
2.  Diverse stakeholder input is used to shape programs
3.  Client satisfaction
4.  Best Practices/Exemplary Programs
5.  Knowledge/Attitude/Skills/Aspirations (KASA) and Behavioral Change
6.  Economic Impact
7.  Funding for Cooperative Extension

I believe regular review and reflection on how these criteria are reflected in programming would be beneficial for all of us in Extension.  Some areas may closely relate to our role in the organization, but it is good to have an awareness of what defines excellence for the organization as a whole.

The group also provides regular webinars, newsletters and other resources to aid extension in program evaluation.  The March 2012 newsletter contains results of a survey of Extension Directors and Administrators that suggests that personnel other than directors that are utilizing the information collected by the site are in the areas of planning and reporting, program leadership, human resources and communication.  Primary challenges appear to be increasing use and the number of institutions reporting to the site.  Recommended uses for the data include:  institutional comparisons, tracking institutional change over time, grant applications, illustrating critical needs and reporting progress and use of resources (accountability). 

Make reviewing this site a personal professional development goal for yourself today.  We gain value through the collective actions of our organizations.  This program/website will help to make us more aware of our accomplishments, both individually and collectively.

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Social media take home messages from NETC 2012

Social Media Evaluation
We need to determine methods of social media evaluation to determine:
o   Who are we attracting?
o   Are they engaging with us?  How do we define engagement?
o   How are we reaching them?  Which platform?  What type of interaction?
o   What are we trying to do and are we doing it?  Need to establish goals, preferably before beginning to be sure you are using the right platform/approach

Levels of evaluation and evaluation methods – run weekly since twitter only archives 7-8 days
o   Sentiment – content analysis tools –
§  CTI
§  Excel Analytics for Twitter – provides a tone score.  Can search on hashtag, free download
§   Invivo – very challenging and labor intensive.  Required 10 hours of analysis for an hour on-line chat session. 
o   Attitudes, Perceptions & Behavior – Survey research tools
§  Survey Monkey
§  Instant Survey
o   Reach, Engagement & Action – Analytic Tools – see comparison chart from slides
§  Google Analytics – web pages, new social engagement – how long are visitors there?  Where do they go when they leave?
§  Facebook Insights – page posts - # people reached, look for patterns
§  TweetReach – identify audience through retweets
§  SWIX – Facebook and Twitter, moderate, but only surface - $39/month
§  TweetStats – timing issues
§  Klout and Kred – influence
§  Google spreadsheet – open and run – configure to run automatically
§  URL link shortener – follow link access
o   Need for internal evaluator to facilitate evaluative thinking and document
o   Reflective practice – focus group – Adobe Connect
o   Participating in online networks is an essential skill for extension professionals in an interconnected world. . . core competency
Social Media Management
·         Engage a team in management of facebook pages, but allow to post either as the organization or as an individual
·         Get colleagues to invite friends to “brand” page to increase audience
·         linqto – Facebook App which allows video chat
·         Some counties using Facebook pages to promote county events – connect to Google calendar
Social media - “communication, collaboration, learning and the sharing of resources”  “Facebook is becoming the new internet.” - Luke Wrobleski
Contacts/Presenters:
·         Sarah Baughman – Military Families, VT - @programeval
·         Jerri Caldwell Hammond - @JL_Hammonds
·         Marissa Stone - @Marissa_Stone
·         Luke Wrobleski

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Past and Present - Changes and Similarities

On my way into work this morning I was reflecting on one of the projects I've undertaken in the past couple months - thinking about ways to use social media to increase marketing of Extension programs. A little over 10 years ago, when I moved to the Purdue campus, the charge was to figure out how to deliver extension programming in an online environment that would meet needs and enhance relationships with Extension clientele.

Ten years ago I was focussed on the educational programming. Today I'm looking at programming across the state and more from the marketing perspective. Although, because of my background, I'm thinking too of how as an educator I would utilize today's tools to focus on building relationships with the clientele.

It is interesting to see the number of states and programs as well as individuals out there utilizing social media in Extension so I pay close attention to what they are doing. In addition, I've been looking at what commercial businesses are doing. I believe social media tools have increased our reach in terms of the number of people we can interact with as well as their geographic dispersal. While some people think Extension boundaries match those of the county or state, those boundaries do not exist in an online environment. Many extension programs are becoming more specialized so opportunity to interact with others outside those man-made boundaries may be crucial in providing the educational content to meet a particular client's needs. Further, because the amount of educational programming being delivered in an online environment continues to increase, access to that programming can be convenient regardless of geographic location. As I've been following other states, primarily through their Twitter posts, I've been interested in seeing the types of programs and approaches they are taking. I think this interaction can only strengthen relationships in Extension nationally and internationally and guide us in improving our programming. The interaction provides a type of virtual, continuous professional development opportunity to those that are engaged.

As our reach is increasing, so also are our networks and our opportunity to facilitate the development of virtual communities. I've been hearing a lot about #AgChat lately, although I have another obligation on Tuesday evenings that prevents my participation. (I have been following their tweets.) This appears to be a virtual community based on a common interest in agriculture. They entertain "speakers" who can share with the group and facilitate and encourage group discussion. It sounds a lot like some of the night meetings on specific topics I used to host as a county educator many years ago, but with a lot more convenience and sources of ideas that may be international, and are at least national in origins rather than just lcoal, providing a wider range of diversity in approaches and ideas. This virtual "community" becomes very real in terms of opportunity for educational programming, discussing key issues and identifying potential solutions.

So, in a nutshell, although the tools and capabilities have changed, the primary focus for Extension programming remains on development of relationships. Because of the tools, the nature of those relationships has changed and the definition of a community has greatly expanded. The quality and relevance of the educational programming remains important but the mode of delivery has changed.